A Stronger Yuan Is Manna For Emerging Markets
China and its currency are dominating debate in the U.S., but they are having their greatest impact in the emerging markets. Economically, of course, much of the emerging world is extremely sensitive to developments in China. But the yuan is also turning into a critical variable as it begins, ever so slowly, to behave at least a little like a conventional floating currency.
Emerging markets are sensitive to a stronger dollar. If they have borrowed in dollars, a strengthening U.S. currency means higher interest costs, and can make it harder to avoid a debt crisis. Argentina’s pain this year owed much to problems at home, but would have been easier to avoid if the dollar had stayed weak.
The yuan remains pegged against the dollar, but the peg is growing weaker. A strengthening Chinese currency implies that there is no great pressure on China, and allows other emerging currencies to strengthen. And, more ominously, vice versa. It also acts as a proxy for the risk or seriousness of a trade war. When China’s currency weakens, this means an intensification of trade hostilities, which means problems for China’s economy and for the emerging markets complex as a whole. This is how the Chinese exchange rate has moved compared to JPMorgan’s broad index of emerging market currencies since the beginning of last year:


Last week, all banks’ reserve requirement ratios were cut, to their lowest levels since 2007, allowing more lending across the economy. This helped to strengthen the yuan and revive emerging markets across the globe. It is questionable whether the Chinese authorities really can stimulate at will, in the way that once seemed possible, and it also looks as though they have some work on their hands. This week began with the release of new Chinese data on imports and exports, which showed export growth had virtually stopped. The following chart includes a 12-month moving average to help account for the distortions that come with the annual shutdown around the lunar new year:
The new stimulus will not necessarily come to the rescue. Andrew Batson and Thomas Gatley of Gavekal Economics describe the policy as a “conflicted easing,” the result of the contradictions the Chinese authorities now face. There are areas in need of stimulation, and others (notably housing) that seem overheated. It is hard for monetary policy to discriminate, but China’s technocrats are trying. The Gavekal authors comment that “the new system separates the pricing of mortgages and corporate loans, allowing the PBOC to set a floor for mortgages above the loan prime rate.” The point, they suggest, is to allow the central bank to make loans for corporations cheaper without also stimulating the housing market – which is normally the most rate-sensitive sector, and thus offers the most direct way for monetary policy to stimulate the economy. As they put it, “the PBOC seems to be deliberately making monetary policy less effective!”
For the time being, a slightly stronger yuan offers a measure of support to other emerging markets. But they may not get as much help as they hope from China’s monetary authorities.
Bloomberg.
Comments are closed.